“Rice is a beautiful food. It is beautiful when it grows – precision rows of sparkling green stalks shooting up to reach the hot summer sun. It is beautiful when harvested, autumn gold sheaves piled in diked, patchwork paddies. It is beautiful when, once threshed, it enters granary bins like a cataract of tiny seed-pearls. It is beautiful when cooked by a practiced hand, pure white and sweetly fragranced.”
– Shizuo Tsuji, Japanese Cooking: A Simple Art (1980)
There’s a reason I chose Gohan as the name for my latest cookbook; it means rice, specifically a bowl of perfectly steamed, slightly sticky Japanese rice. It’s also the word you can find used to mean breakfast (“morning rice”), lunch (“noon rice”) or dinner (“evening rice”) and the word you’d shout out to your children to let them know dinner’s on the table.
Rice is my soul food. I could live without pasta for the rest of my life but if there is one thing I crave every now and then when I need to feel nourished, to feel like myself, it’s a bowl of steamed rice.
So I was super curious when food writer Lee Tran Lam recently released a new podcast for SBS called Should you really eat that? quoting an Australian dietician, Susie Burrell, who wrote in this Sydney Morning Herald piece that rice is one thing she’d never put in her shopping trolley — a statement that made me bristle because of course lacks any kind of consideration for cultural importance of foods for like half the planet.
Burrell says, “Although it is considered a dietary staple, white rice lacks the nutrient density wholegrain brown rice offers and with an extremely high glycemic index, is exceptionally easy to overeat. If I am reaching for a family meal base, I opt for wholemeal pasta or quinoa, or serve dishes that use rice as an ingredient with cauliflower rice.”
Let’s be clear about one thing: cauliflower is not rice.
I asked
what she thought about this (and I would love to hear what aka Antiracist Dietician thinks about this too!) and she made some really interesting points, including:“The biggest issue I have with these types of lists is that it sets up a 'right' and 'wrong' way to eat based on a very privileged identity. The foods listed are almost always extremely Euro-centric and middle-class, and focus almost exclusively on the nutritional value of food. Nutrition is only one of the many complex reasons we make food choices. Didactic prescriptions like this fail to consider disabilities, cost, cultural preferences, allergies, neurodivergence, or how under late stage capitalism, many of us just don't have a choice.
Looking at white rice through the (admittedly narrow) lens of nutrition, we rarely eat rice on its own. It's usually paired with an egg, meat or fish, with vegetables, or with a sauce (like a coconut based one such as in a Thai inspired curry). The addition of other ingredients adds protein, fat, and fibre that help slow down the release of sugar into the bloodstream after a meal. Similarly, the way some cultures eat rice is as leftovers, like in fried rice. Cooking and cooling white rice produces resistant starch - this means it will have a lower glycaemic load compared to fresh rice which can be helpful for people managing their blood glucose levels (but I want to stress that fresh rice isn't something you need to be afraid of!).
Many of our nutritional guidelines are based on white European ideals that fail to acknowledge that there are dietary patterns outside of the 'Mediterranean' diet (which itself isn't a monolith), that support wellbeing. Again looking at foods through the lens of nutrition misses the richness of culture and history that shapes cuisines. It fails to acknowledge that not everyone wants to (or should) eat like a white European, and that there are tangible impacts of cutting people off from their cultural foodways, or telling them that the foods they are familiar with are 'unhealthy' and need to be given the cauliflower rice treatment.
No one is eating white rice on it’s own. In Japanese meals, rice is always part of a bigger meal, it’s like the bread at a Tuscan meal — it’s never a meal without it, but it’s the only thing you’re eating.
It is an understatement to say rice is the most important dish in Japanese cuisine. It is the very essence of Japanese culture. It is not only the staple dish of every meal, whether humble or formal course after course degustation, but rice is also vital for its role in making sake and vinegar, ingredients that are so essential in flavouring dishes and preserving food such as pickles – Japanese cuisine wouldn't be what it is without these ingredients.
Historically, even outside of the kitchen, rice – as none of the plant was wasted – was important also for its use in making paper and glue for books, for fuel, tatami mats and building materials. It was even used like currency.
Japan's available arable land (only about twelve percent) is a small proportion compared to its mountains and forests, but like a lot of Asia, it has very humid summers and a higher than average rainfall. The wet weather, along with the abundant rivers found running through the mountain ranges, is the perfect climate for wet-rice cultivation but not without its challenges.
In the foothills of the mountains of Nagano, I visited Sashara (below) where I was told of the founders of the village, eleven families, who, almost 400 years ago cleared the bamboo in the area to create terraces on the land for rice fields in what is known as the “rice line”, a border of which rice does not grow due to the harsh mountain winters.
The families bonded together in order to cultivate rice.
They diverted mountain rivers into pools to be warmed by the sun before being let out through hand-dug, kilometres-long water network called segi in a shared irrigation system to flood the village's rice fields. This sharing of water resources among rice farming communities was common in Japan and, together with the fact that wet-rice farming was incredibly labour-intensive, meant that living close, working harmoniously together and relying on each was important to successfully grow and harvest the rice.
Each harvest was a joint effort. Each grain of rice a result of the hard work of many.
Rice in Japanese culture was also considered an important form of protein, seeing as for about twelve centuries — right up until 1872 — the killing of animals was condoned and therefore meat was not eaten. “Protein was ingested from rice rather than from meat or milk,” writes historian Naomishi Ishige.
Author Zenjiro Watanabe paints this picture: “The fact that rice is the staple of the Japanese diet was in fact dictated by nature and the Japanese climate. Moreover, the islands of Japan are blessed with abundant marine resources. With no need for meat, a community with a diet of rice and fish was born.”
A bowl of steamed Japanese rice is quite unlike its equivalent in any other culture.
Japan's unique rice cultivar, in fact, is a soft, short grain rice, which when cooked perfectly consists of grains that are incredibly moist and stick to each other, which is part of the secret of being able to eat it easily with chopsticks. A bowl of plain Japanese rice is a canvas to the umami-rich sauces and dishes that are eaten with it, but there are also many variations on the regular bowl of rice, usually seasonal. Chestnuts might be cooked together with rice in late autumn, or perhaps fresh peas in the spring and corn in the summer. My grandmother would sometimes cook the rice in fragrant habucha, roasted cassia seed tea, for a rice porridge, a dish that my mother likes if she isn't feeling well.
Often a plain bowl of hot rice might be served with just a very fresh raw egg yolk and a splash of soy sauce on top, to mix through quickly with chopsticks. When we were children my mother used to scramble the egg for us with the rice, cooking it a bit like a quick fried rice. It is still my go-to comfort food, and my childrens’ comfort too. It is just a bowl full of love.
— Gohan events coming up! —
I’m getting ready for a book tour in Australia starting in November. As they become finalised I will put them all on my events page here and those that are already open for registry have a link (a few more things to iron out) but for now here is a peek!
Virtual
October 25 — I’ll be in conversation online with Kenji J Lopez for Seattle cookbook bookshop, Booklarder! 12pm Pacific time, register to listen in here.
Sydney
November 23 — author lunch at LuMi dining in conversation with Palisa Anderson (who you’ll also hear talking about living in Japan on Lee Tran’s podcast!)
November 25 — all day cooking class, we will prepare a Japanese breakfast together (here’s why I love Japanese breakfasts most of all). Here is more about my Sydney events for now.
Melbourne
November 28 — author lunch at Ima Project in conversation with Julia Busuttil Nishimura
November 29 — author talk at Books for Cooks with nibbles from Gohan
November 30 — workshop at The Fermentary
Franklin, Tasmania
December 1 — Drinks and Q&A at The Bowmont
December 3 — Japanese home cooking workshop at The Bowmont
Robertson, NSW
December 9 — cooking workshop at Moonacres Cooking School
Canberra
December 6 — author talk at Asia Bookroom
December 10 — drinks and Q&A at Verity Lane
Orange, NSW
December 14 — drinks and author chat with Sophie Hansen (more info TBC)
December 15 — cooking workshop at Sophie Hansen’s farm kitchen
I'm with you. I greatly dislike the click-baity grand proclamations from journalists or writers about any form of sustenance being labeled as "bad". It's disingenuous and extremely problematic. I deal with the damage it does to people like my father-in-law who falls for all that foolishness, and then has to take pills and other "potions" to remedy the issues caused by eliminating whole categories from his diet because those categories were deemed "bad".
Emiko, what a lovely tribute to rice in all its dimensions!
And thanks so much for mentioning the podcast as a spark for some of your ideas today as well - that was a big surprise!
I totally agree with you: food is so much more than strict nutritional stats or isolated nutritional details, it can represent a whole culture (or many cultures!) in many ways and that’s why I used that Burrell quote - it’s a jumping off point for conversations, but not representative of the world view presented by the podcast (because I’d definitely never tell people to remove white rice forever from their diets, given that I grew up literally surrounded by it at home)!
I love the work of the dietitian you quoted and Dr Evangeline Mantzioris makes similar points in the podcast - you never eat rice in isolation really, and what you eat it with (like lemon) can affect the GI levels in a good way. And she mentioned how rice can be a good source of resistant starch, too, and cited staples around the world (from sushi to arancini) that celebrate cooked-then-cooled grains (we probably didn’t even realise these were examples of good-for-you resistant starch as we enjoyed them)!
But as Dr Evangeline says, we just have to keep an eye out on how long we leave them out for, as no one wants things to get into food-poisoning territory.
And yes, I love how rice is used in so many ways in Japanese culture - even down to the tatami mats (I love how Palisa would describe how hers would change colour during the seasons in Japan, how it would start fragrant and green and settle into a gold straw colour). I hope when Palisa does the event with you, she talks about the Thai rice she mentions in the podcast, the one that’s apparently so good it makes you forget your husband!
Excited for the launch of your book in Australia, as I’ve loved following its progress on your newsletter. Only another week to go!!